When it comes to home improvement, many homeowners assume that replacing old fixtures is the best solution. However, the hidden costs of replacement—both in terms of money and time—often go unnoticed. Resurfacing is a cost-effective alternative that delivers the same fresh, modern look without the headaches of demolition and installation. Let’s break down the true cost comparison.
1. The Cost of Replacing a Bathtub vs. Resurfacing
A brand-new bathtub may seem affordable at first, but the total cost of replacement goes far beyond the price of the tub itself.
Cost Comparison:
• New Bathtub: $500 – $1,500
• Demolition & Removal: $300 – $800
• Plumbing Adjustments: $500 – $1,200
• Installation Labor: $800 – $2,000
• Total Replacement Cost: $2,100 – $5,500
• Resurfacing Cost: $300 – $700
Benefits of Resurfacing:
✅ Resurfacing Saves You Thousands – A refinished bathtub looks brand new for a fraction of the cost.
✅ Less Hassle – No need to tear out walls or mess with plumbing.
✅ Faster Turnaround – Resurfacing is done in one day, while replacement takes a week or more.
2. The Cost of Replacing vs. Resurfacing Countertops
Granite or quartz countertops are a beautiful upgrade, but they come with a hefty price tag when you factor in labor, materials, and removal costs.
Cost Comparison:
• New Countertops: $2,000 – $5,000
• Removal of Old Countertops: $300 – $800
• Installation Labor: $1,000 – $2,500
• Total Replacement Cost: $3,300 – $8,300
• Resurfacing Cost: $300 – $900
Benefits of Resurfacing:
✅ Resurfacing Saves Up to 90% – Achieve a high-end look without the high-end cost.
✅ Custom Finishes Available – Get the look of granite, quartz, or marble without replacing.
✅ No Disruptive Construction – No demolition or kitchen downtime required.
3. The Cost of Replacing vs. Resurfacing Cabinets
Cabinet replacement is one of the most expensive home remodeling projects, but resurfacing offers an affordable alternative.
Cost Comparison:
• New Cabinets: $4,000 – $15,000
• Removal & Disposal: $500 – $1,500
• Installation Labor: $2,000 – $5,000
• Total Replacement Cost: $6,500 – $21,500
• Resurfacing Cost: $500 – $1,200
Benefits of Resurfacing:
✅ Resurfacing Saves Up to 80% – Keep your existing cabinets but give them a modern look.
✅ Choose Your Color & Finish – Easily match your updated kitchen or bathroom style.
✅ Faster & Less Messy – No need for a full remodel—resurfacing is completed in a few days.
The True Hidden Costs of Replacement
Beyond the price tag, replacing bathtubs, countertops, and cabinets comes with additional hidden costs:
❌ Extended Timelines – Most replacements take weeks to complete.
❌ Unexpected Repairs – Removing fixtures often reveals hidden plumbing or structural issues.
❌ Permit & Contractor Fees – Some replacements require city permits and licensed professionals.
Why Resurfacing is the Smarter Choice
If your surfaces are structurally sound but just outdated or worn, resurfacing is the best option. It saves you money, avoids demolition, and provides the same fresh look as new installations.
Ready to Save Time and Money? Let’s Talk!
Hitchcock Contracting specializes in professional resurfacing services that deliver beautiful, long-lasting results at a fraction of the cost of replacement.